UCANEWS Asia Logo A service of UCA News
Local Stories
Site Search

Priest celibacy rule ‘cruel’ and ‘archaic’: Aussie judge

smaller font larger font print this article email this article to a friend
Priest celibacy rule ‘cruel’ and ‘archaic’: Aussie judge thumbnail

An Australian judge sentencing a Sydney priest to jail for an internet grooming offence has condemned the celibacy required of the Catholic priesthood as “cruel” and “archaic”.

Father Robert MacGregor Fuller received a maximum of 18 months in jail for grooming and procuring a child under the age of 16, but was given a six-month parole period and six months off his sentence for an early guilty plea, The Australian reported.

He had told the court he masturbated “for my own personal sexual needs”. In response, the judge said it must be agonising to be a Catholic priest.

“I’m not a Catholic,” Sydney District Court judge Allan Hughes was quoted as saying. “I do not regard (that) celibacy (should be) imposed on people. That is because it is a suppression of human instinct. It must be agonising. I don’t know why they (the church) don’t change their rules. It is archaic. It’s cruel, cruel.”

But the judge said children were vulnerable and sexually innocent and “for an adult to exploit them is repugnant”, the ABC added.

Fr Fuller, who had served for six years at All Saints church in Liverpool, in south-west Sydney, was reported last year as having used a webcam to broadcast himself masturbating to ‘Katie’, who was in fact an undercover detective.

He was suspended by the Archdiocese of Sydney when he was arrested. Sydney’s Cardinal George Pell is quoted by The Australian as saying about yesterday’s sentence: “Justice has run its course.”

FULL STORY @

Judge denounces `cruel’ celibacy of Catholic priests (The Australian)

Priest jailed but celibacy vow ‘cruel’ (ABC)



1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (2 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

293 words

Share this article: Share/Save/Bookmark

  • tonydec123
    As if only celibates do what this priest does; is the judge saying that married men don't do what this priest has done? The argument, if there is one (there is a gratuitous assumption here that is not articulated), is utterly hogwash.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Stay in Touch
Subscribe to the CathNews Asia, Free newsletter.
 
Name
Surname
Email

Subscribe to our feed (RSS)
Share a story with us
Follow us on Twitter
Stories Spotlight
  1. Vatican admits real estate ‘errors’ - 2 emails
  2. People Power Bishop Claver dead at 81 - 2 emails
  3. Vatican-approved bishop ordained in Taizhou - 1 email
  4. Muslim wives not satisfied with polygamy: Study - 1 email
  5. Blasphemy accused killings shock Pakistan - 1 email
  6. Man U shirts insult Allah: Malaysian mufti - 1 email
  7. What can Myanmar refugee kids dream about? - 1 email
  1. Punishment 'too short' for Khmer Rouge torturer
  2. Dead Sea Scrolls may be 'Temple treasure'
  3. KOMISO
  4. Pope names first nuncio for Russia
  5. Muslims fined over ‘cow-head’ incident
  6. Raped Kandamal nun 'a witness to Light and Truth'
  7. Video - UCA News Magazine
  8. Indonesian church attacks on the rise
  9. 'Global south' gaining in Christian influence: Study
  10. Caravaggio, no: L'Osservatore backtracks
  1. Cardinal Dias writes to Chinese bishops, priests
  2. Indon church joins ILO call for child-labor ban
  3. Filipino parents drop sex education lawsuit
  4. Repeal blasphemy laws, WCC tells Pakistan
  5. Homosexuality a ‘defect’: Chile Cardinal affirms
  6. Pope names first nuncio for Russia
  7. Does Beijing really want bishops appointed by the pope?
  8. The trial and sentencing of Comrade Duch
  9. Raped Kandamal nun ‘a witness to Light and Truth’
  10. Video - UCA News Magazine
  1. Define "independent." And what gives you the right to define it, anyway?...
    Said Mstephens268 on 2010-07-28 03:16:00
  2. is this report seemed to specify where the error was?...
    Said Jersey City Condo on 2010-07-27 15:09:41
  3. Do want they want to do. Next election is coming. Show your dissatisfaction thro...
    Said disgruntled on 2010-07-27 08:19:22
  4. The Mining Act permits mining firms to be 100% foreign-owned and, most surprisin...
    Said Reynard Loki on 2010-07-25 21:47:29
  5. Although I agree that combating trafficking- in-persons is one of several pressi...
    Said profpatt on 2010-07-24 01:20:05
  6. The headline of the story is grossly exaggerated. God is not mentioned even once...
    Said George on 2010-07-21 17:25:32
  7. when is the next assembly this year?...
    Said Frtced_ssf on 2010-07-19 17:27:53
  8. Brother's now more than ever we need to make sure we do the right thing we a...
    Said BROTHER on 2010-07-19 14:33:02
  9. We are with you in prayer. former missionary in Pakistan. we stand for truth and...
    Said Bro. Damian Susath, FSC on 2010-07-19 09:44:26
  10. I believe the way to this challenge is to increase evanglization effort, the apo...
    Said Sebastian Liew on 2010-07-19 08:55:18