UCANEWS Asia Logo A service of UCA News
Local Stories
Site Search

Filipino liturgist challenges ‘reform of the reform’

smaller font larger font print this article email this article to a friend
Filipino liturgist challenges ‘reform of the reform’ thumbnail

World-renowned expert in liturgical study, Fr Anscar Chupungco, has challenged recent announcements on liturgical reform, identifying their inability to fuse together the two basic concepts of Vatican II’s liturgical renewal.

His comments were made at the launch on Friday of a new course in Liturgical Studies to be offered by The Broken Bay Institute and University of Newcastle.

Chupungco noted that recent statements which called for a reform of Vatican II’s reform were part of an agenda to turn the clock back 50 years.

This call “seems to conveniently forget that since Vatican II, the Church has been marching with the times, acknowledging the changes in social and religious culture, and adopting new pastoral strategies,” said Fr Chupungco, the first Filipino priest on the Pontifical Institute’s Faculty.

Fr Chupungco urged students to become “equipped with a critical mind that allows them to weigh the value of new norms and directives, though always in the spirit of ecclesial obedience”.

MEDIA RELEASE

Broken Bay Institute launches new program in Liturgical Studies

PHOTO CREDIT

Flickr / CC BY-2.0



1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (2 votes, average: 3.50 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

213 words

Share this article: Share/Save/Bookmark

  • Ecclesia Semper Reformanda
    Fr. Anscar has the credentials and has served in the Papal Commission on Liturgy for a long time. He is also well versed with the developments and changes that resulted to the Vatican II.
  • laurie clegg
    I recently attended a Tridentine Mass, an experience which reinforced my conviction that the reforms initiated by Vatican 2 should be defended, should be promoted amongst those too young to remember what our liturgy was like before the Council, and be taken further.
    The current translation could be improved, but only to make it even more accessible to the laity. In addressing God in our own prayers, and in the Mass, we should always remember that Jesus asked us to call God our Father. A grovelling approach to our Creator should not be mistaken for reverence.
  • Louis Figueroa
    Let's not kid ouselves for a moment. To say "the church has been marching with the times" is a severe and misguided notion; rather, there have been enclaves within the church willing to sacrifice its sacredness to follow the ways of the world. The bottom line is that the current liturgy is in dire need of reform, as the language is far too common and lacks the reverence that should be present when worshipping God; further, it has contributed to a generation who has lost sight of their place before the Almighty.

    The current translation is very far from what was orignally intended stated in Latin and quite frankly, when the vernacular used is too common, people will look upon that which is worshipped as common.

    There may be many new norms and directives guiding priests; however, the eternal truth is the eternal truth and never changes and that truth is that Our God deserves the highest reverence, and part of helping laity to develop that reverence is the use of language and gestures.

    Honestly, if Fr Anscar Chupungco cannot envision what I have spoken of, he needs to visit a tridentine mass and become with the sacred tradition of the Church and the Mass promulgated by Pope Pius V. Perhaps some time on his knees before the Eucharist will help him and others to understand my point, as it is imperative to remember that in the Sacrifice of the Mass we behold the King of Kings, Master of the Universe, the true God. Keeping the previous in mind, how could we offer Him anything but the best in language, music and actions (gestures)?
  • I am flabbagasted that Fr Chupungco should say that the "chruch has been marching with the times". Are "the times" so good that the church has simply to follow it and all will be well? As G.K Chesterton once said, the church should not simply move with the times, but move the times. Also, a dead thing can always flow with the current, only a living thing can swim against it.
  • Frank Carson
    I do not know what is wrong with the church marching with the times, while in fact, you guys are using what the present moment offers, and may I say, even enjoy using these gadgets, the freedom of speech, to express what you think and know, and also to display what you do not know. Can you say that you are not marching with the times? To march with the times has been the vision not by Fr. Chupungco only, but by the Second Vatican Council. It is the whole orientation of a movement that recognizes that the present is not something to be considered bad. Remember the late Pope Blessed John XXIII, when asked why he would be calling a council, he replied that he would open the window to let fresh air come in. The Council was intended to show the so-called the "prophets of doom", those who mistrusted the present world that this world, the present world we live in has something positive to offer, that dialogue with it is possible, that what the world may offer, may be used for evangelization. Dialogue here would not mean just following what the world dictates. There is also the so-called critical collaboration.
    Sad that what caught your attention was that line which did not comprise the whole talk, and was not even original to Fr. Anscar!
blog comments powered by Disqus
Stay in Touch
Subscribe to the CathNews Asia, Free newsletter.
 
Name
Surname
Email

Subscribe to our feed (RSS)
Share a story with us
Follow us on Twitter
Stories Spotlight
  1. Vatican admits real estate ‘errors’ - 2 emails
  2. People Power Bishop Claver dead at 81 - 2 emails
  3. Vatican-approved bishop ordained in Taizhou - 1 email
  4. Muslim wives not satisfied with polygamy: Study - 1 email
  5. Blasphemy accused killings shock Pakistan - 1 email
  6. Man U shirts insult Allah: Malaysian mufti - 1 email
  7. What can Myanmar refugee kids dream about? - 1 email
  1. Punishment 'too short' for Khmer Rouge torturer
  2. Dead Sea Scrolls may be 'Temple treasure'
  3. KOMISO
  4. Pope names first nuncio for Russia
  5. Muslims fined over ‘cow-head’ incident
  6. Raped Kandamal nun 'a witness to Light and Truth'
  7. Video - UCA News Magazine
  8. Indonesian church attacks on the rise
  9. 'Global south' gaining in Christian influence: Study
  10. Caravaggio, no: L'Osservatore backtracks
  1. Cardinal Dias writes to Chinese bishops, priests
  2. Indon church joins ILO call for child-labor ban
  3. Filipino parents drop sex education lawsuit
  4. Repeal blasphemy laws, WCC tells Pakistan
  5. Homosexuality a ‘defect’: Chile Cardinal affirms
  6. Pope names first nuncio for Russia
  7. Does Beijing really want bishops appointed by the pope?
  8. The trial and sentencing of Comrade Duch
  9. Raped Kandamal nun ‘a witness to Light and Truth’
  10. Video - UCA News Magazine
  1. Define "independent." And what gives you the right to define it, anyway?...
    Said Mstephens268 on 2010-07-28 03:16:00
  2. is this report seemed to specify where the error was?...
    Said Jersey City Condo on 2010-07-27 15:09:41
  3. Do want they want to do. Next election is coming. Show your dissatisfaction thro...
    Said disgruntled on 2010-07-27 08:19:22
  4. The Mining Act permits mining firms to be 100% foreign-owned and, most surprisin...
    Said Reynard Loki on 2010-07-25 21:47:29
  5. Although I agree that combating trafficking- in-persons is one of several pressi...
    Said profpatt on 2010-07-24 01:20:05
  6. The headline of the story is grossly exaggerated. God is not mentioned even once...
    Said George on 2010-07-21 17:25:32
  7. when is the next assembly this year?...
    Said Frtced_ssf on 2010-07-19 17:27:53
  8. Brother's now more than ever we need to make sure we do the right thing we a...
    Said BROTHER on 2010-07-19 14:33:02
  9. We are with you in prayer. former missionary in Pakistan. we stand for truth and...
    Said Bro. Damian Susath, FSC on 2010-07-19 09:44:26
  10. I believe the way to this challenge is to increase evanglization effort, the apo...
    Said Sebastian Liew on 2010-07-19 08:55:18